- Rationale
-
tspec-archivecloses a change after only structural validation (antora-tracer validate), which checks roles, relations, statuses, and dangling references but cannot catch conformance gaps. A requirement can be satisfied on paper yet not in the repository, such as a field named differently than the change declared or a page path that does not resolve. Conformance verification is currently ad hoc, so a change can reachclosedwith no independent check that the implementation satisfies its requirements. Verification has no standalone lifecycle: it only ever precedes close, so it belongs inside archive, not in a seventh skill. - Outcome
-
tspec-archiveruns an independent, read-only conformance review before advancing a change toclosed. A cold reviewer reads the change, its addressed requirements, and its recorded decisions, checks each requirement against the repository state, and emits a per-requirement verdict. Archive closes only on a clean verdict. - Out-of-scope
-
A dedicated
tspec-verify-changeskill. New states or transitions:verifiedtoclosedis unchanged, and the gate is archive behavior, not a new state-machine rule.tspec-validatestays structural-only, andtspec-applystill self-advances toverified.
CHG-006 — Verify change conformance in archive, not a separate skill
Addresses